Help needed to identify this Cinderella stamp please?
Moderator: Volunteer Moderator Team
- pacneil
- Well on the way to 25 post Senior Member
- Posts: 11
- Joined: 14 Dec 2022 12:21
- Location: Poway, California USA
Help needed to identify this Cinderella stamp please?
I wonder if anyone can identify this "stamp"?
Last edited by Global Admin on 22 Jan 2023 04:12, edited 2 times in total.
Reason: Expanded very vague and lazy 2 word heading, to make more sense to members, (read Rule 10) and turned it into a QUESTION of some kind and moved to CORRECT Forum
Reason: Expanded very vague and lazy 2 word heading, to make more sense to members, (read Rule 10) and turned it into a QUESTION of some kind and moved to CORRECT Forum
- vicaf60
- 2500 Stampboards Post - Senior Guru
- Posts: 4728
- Joined: 22 Oct 2013 04:59
- Location: Minsk, Belarus
Re: Unknown Cinderella
It is Ukrainian, issued in abroad in 1946
- BigSaint
- WINNER! Stampboards Poster Of The Month
- Posts: 108950
- Joined: 16 Nov 2012 11:26
- Location: Cheltenham, Australia
Re: Help needed to identify this cinderella?
pacneil
I reproduce Rule 10 for your reference, meaningless two word headings are unacceptable here:
"10. Create Descriptive Thread Headings, or Titles
Make thread heading titles as specific and descriptive as possible. WE do NOT charge by the word! And we do NOT do lazy 2 or 3 word headings. Sometimes posters will start a thread with a VERY vague general title such as, "Guess what?" or "Help needed" or "Hinges" or "US1dollar" or "Russia" or "Fault on Scott 539?" These are all totally meaningless to most members, who are busy, and simply do not have time to click on such thread headings. And never ASSUME more than a small % of members have a Scott, SG, Michel or Unitrade cat. A concise title will mean YOUR thread gets a strong google ranking, and someone in a month - or a year, may then find it on a web search, and join up, and answer your question. Happens ALL the time.

Be as SPECIFIC as possible in your thread titles, and if you want to improve or change your thread's title after you create it, ask a Moderator for help - or edit it yourself, which you can do within an hour of posting it. Add the YEAR and COUNTRY involved, and a PHOTO in all cases is our policy in post #1 - see Rule 11 for how to do that. This board has 25,000 real members, from over 180 countries. Do not ASSUME they can read your mind, or have YOUR catalogue. If you are asking a question about an Australia 1937 3d Blue, KGVI head, Die 1A identification .. make THAT the heading - do not start a vague thread headed "3d Blue Die". Never use all capital letter headings - that is regarded as rude and "Shouting" on the web. It is all basic common sense really."
You will find a link to all of the Rules above. Please read them.
Brad for the Board Moderators.
I reproduce Rule 10 for your reference, meaningless two word headings are unacceptable here:
"10. Create Descriptive Thread Headings, or Titles
Make thread heading titles as specific and descriptive as possible. WE do NOT charge by the word! And we do NOT do lazy 2 or 3 word headings. Sometimes posters will start a thread with a VERY vague general title such as, "Guess what?" or "Help needed" or "Hinges" or "US1dollar" or "Russia" or "Fault on Scott 539?" These are all totally meaningless to most members, who are busy, and simply do not have time to click on such thread headings. And never ASSUME more than a small % of members have a Scott, SG, Michel or Unitrade cat. A concise title will mean YOUR thread gets a strong google ranking, and someone in a month - or a year, may then find it on a web search, and join up, and answer your question. Happens ALL the time.


Be as SPECIFIC as possible in your thread titles, and if you want to improve or change your thread's title after you create it, ask a Moderator for help - or edit it yourself, which you can do within an hour of posting it. Add the YEAR and COUNTRY involved, and a PHOTO in all cases is our policy in post #1 - see Rule 11 for how to do that. This board has 25,000 real members, from over 180 countries. Do not ASSUME they can read your mind, or have YOUR catalogue. If you are asking a question about an Australia 1937 3d Blue, KGVI head, Die 1A identification .. make THAT the heading - do not start a vague thread headed "3d Blue Die". Never use all capital letter headings - that is regarded as rude and "Shouting" on the web. It is all basic common sense really."

You will find a link to all of the Rules above. Please read them.
Brad for the Board Moderators.
Specialist Collector of World Horse Racing Covers, Melbourne Cup & Kentucky Derby, & JFK fdcs.
- vicaf60
- 2500 Stampboards Post - Senior Guru
- Posts: 4728
- Joined: 22 Oct 2013 04:59
- Location: Minsk, Belarus
Re: Help needed to identify this cinderella?
According to Khomiak's catalogue. it was issued in 1946 in Munchen, Germany, by Charitative Sanitary Service to raise funds for widows and orphans of Ukrainian anti-communist fighters.
The issue contained 3 stamps - blue, bronze and bluish olive.
The issue contained 3 stamps - blue, bronze and bluish olive.
- pacneil
- Well on the way to 25 post Senior Member
- Posts: 11
- Joined: 14 Dec 2022 12:21
- Location: Poway, California USA
Re: Help needed to identify this cinderella?
Please explain how you THINK I violated this rule? Or are you just being pedantic? My heading was greater than 3 words and described what I was trying to learn. I had a picture of the object. I've been using bulletin boards since the late '80s and have never had someone call me out like this. Guess I'll spend less time posting here.BigSaint wrote: ↑21 Jan 2023 09:09 pacneil
I reproduce Rule 10 for your reference, meaningless two word headings are unacceptable here:
"10. Create Descriptive Thread Headings, or Titles
Make thread heading titles as specific and descriptive as possible. WE do NOT change by the word! And we do NOT do lazy 2 or 3 word headings. Sometimes posters will start a thread with a VERY vague general title such as, "Guess what?" or "Help needed" or "Hinges" or "US1dollar" or "Russia" or "Fault on Scott 539?" These are all totally meaningless to most members, who are busy, and simply do not have time to click on such thread headings. And never ASSUME more than a small % of members have a Scott, SG, Michel or Unitrade cat. A concise title will mean YOUR thread gets a strong google ranking, and someone in a month - or a year, may then find it on a web search, and join up, and answer your question. Happens ALL the time.![]()
Be as SPECIFIC as possible in your thread titles, and if you want to improve or change your thread's title after you create it, ask a Moderator for help - or edit it yourself, which you can do within an hour of posting it. Add the YEAR and COUNTRY involved, and a PHOTO in all cases is our policy in post #1 - see Rule 11 for how to do that. This board has 25,000 real members, from over 180 countries. Do not ASSUME they can read your mind, or have YOUR catalogue. If you are asking a question about an Australia 1937 3d Blue, KGVI head, Die 1A identification .. make THAT the heading - do not start a vague thread headed "3d Blue Die". Never use all capital letter headings - that is regarded as rude and "Shouting" on the web. It is all basic common sense really."
You will find a link to all of the Rules above. Please read them.
Brad for the Board Moderators.
Have a wonderful day!
- pacneil
- Well on the way to 25 post Senior Member
- Posts: 11
- Joined: 14 Dec 2022 12:21
- Location: Poway, California USA
Re: Help needed to identify this cinderella?
What is this "Khomiak's catalogue" of which you speak? Where can I acquire a copy? Always interested in philatelic books that relate to Ukraine.
- Global Admin
- The Sheriff
- Posts: 71005
- Joined: 18 Apr 2007 22:57
- Location: Tombstone, Oz
- Contact:
Re: Help needed to identify this cinderella?
No it was TWO words - 'Unknown Cinderella' (clearly shown in first response) - totally lazy beyond belief, and totally meaningless to anyone.
Please read Rule 32 (you were clearly referred to our simple Rules) re disputing Moderator directions -
https://www.stampboards.com/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=2556
You have a week's vacation now, to read it several times, along with Rule 10.


You get a fast and accurate answer to your vague query, yet not one word of thanks to the member kindly assisting, but still the whines. Typical American 'Bull In A China Shop' newbie response.

Admin
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest